An analysis of the article clothing dress codes and uniforms by david l hudson

Christopher Cascio School uniform policies are implemented in schools all across the United States and are often the source of heated debate.

An analysis of the article clothing dress codes and uniforms by david l hudson

Pupils in Turkey, School girls, Spain, It is difficult to trace the origins of the uniform as there is no comprehensive written history, but rather a variety of known influences. School uniforms are believed to be a practice which dates to the 16th century in the United Kingdom.

It is believed that the Christ Hospital School in London in was the first school to use a school uniform. Universities, primary schools and secondary schools used uniforms as a marker of class and status. In the United Statesa movement toward using uniforms in state schools began when Bill Clinton addressed it in the State of the Unionsaying: These theories and studies elaborate on the benefits and also the shortcomings of uniform policies.

The issue of nature vs.

School uniform policies are implemented in schools all across the United States and are often the source of heated debate. Supporters claim uniforms make schools safer and even improve student performance. School Uniforms: Friend or Foe? Do they really make a difference? Let's take a look at the History School uniforms have been in use since the 16th century in England and made their way over to the U.S. Then the debates began. School Dress Codes Limit Students' Freedom of Expression Students' Rights, "What Are the Constitutional Objections to Mandatory Dress Codes and Uniform Policies?" David L. Hudson Jr. "Clothing, Dress Codes & Uniforms: Overview," First Amendment Center.

With uniforms also comes a variety of controversies, pros, cons and major legal implications. One of these, the case study of the Long Beach Unified School Districtis most often cited in support of school uniforms and their effectiveness whereas Effects of Student Uniforms on Attendance, Behavior Problems, Substance Use, and Academic Achievement is the most frequently cited research in opposition to the implementation of school uniform policies.

Effects of uniforms on students[ edit ] The case study of the Long Beach Unified School District was the study of the first large, urban school in the United States to implement a uniform policy. The study attributed favourable student behavioral changes and a significant drop in school discipline issues [9] to the mandatory uniform policy.

This case study attributed the following noticeable outcomes to the use of uniforms throughout the district: A study suggested that "instead of directly affecting specific outcomes, uniforms act as a catalyst for change and provide a highly visible opportunity for additional programs" within schools.

In fact, Brunsma et al. According to David Brunsma, one in four public elementary schools and one in eight public middle and high schools in the USA have policies dictating what a student wears to school. As ofthere are currently 23 states that allow school districts to mandate school uniforms.

Although up until this point, The Supreme Court has not ruled on a case involving school uniforms directly, in the decision Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School Districtthe Court ruled that upon entering school, students do not shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech.

In the Australian state of Queensland, Ombudsman Fred Albietz ruled in that state schools may not require uniforms. In Scotland, some local councils that have responsibility for delivering state education do not insist on students wearing a uniform as a precondition to attending and taking part in curricular activities.

Even though the plaintiff appealed the decision, the Fifth Circuit Court also ruled in favour of the school board after implementing a four-step system that is still used today.

Firstly, a school board has to have the right to set up a policy. Secondly, the policy must be determined to support a fundamental interest of the board as a whole. Thirdly, the guidelines cannot have been set for the purpose of censorship. Finally, the limits on student expression cannot be greater than the interest of the board.

As long as these four policies are in place, then no constitutional violation can be claimed. Forney Independent School District[ edit ] In the Forney Independent School District of Forney, Texas inthe school board decided to implement a school uniform policy allowing the students to wear a polo shirtoxford shirt or blouse in four possible colours, and blue or khaki pants or shirts, a skirt or jumper.

While there was some flexibility with shoes, certain types were prohibited along with any sort of baggy clothes. The parents of the Littlefield family requested that their son be exempt from the policy, but were denied.

In response, the Littlefields filed a lawsuit against the school district, under the pretenses that this uniform mandate infringed on their rights as parents to control how they brought up their children and their education.

They even went as far as to cite an infringement on religious freedom, claiming that opting out of the uniforms on the grounds of religion allowed the school to rank the validity of certain religions.

Before trial, the District Court dismissed the case, so the family appealed.

An analysis of the language and tone in the book charlottes web by eb white

As far as the religious freedom violation accusations, the court ruled that the policy did not have a religious goal, and thus did not infringe on religious freedom rights. A junior by the name of Kimberly Jacobs was suspended a total of five times because she wore a religious shirt to school and got cited for uniform violations.

Her family sued the Clark County School District under the claims that her First Amendment rights were being infringed upon and that the uniform policy was causing students to be deprived of due process.SCHOOL DRESS CODE. IMPACT.

An analysis of the article clothing dress codes and uniforms by david l hudson

Your Dress Code Is A Bully The debate on school uniforms and dress codes is intensifying as many parents and educators are increasingly concerned about the trend.

Research Brief Student Dress Codes and Uniforms Dress Codes and Uniforms by David L. Hudson, Jr. codes_uniforms This excellent analysis by a first amendment scholar from the First Amendment Center explores many of the central issues and legal dimensions of school dress codes.

Re "Dressing down school dress codes," Opinion, Sept. 5 Law professor Ruthann Robson opines that a dress code focusing on "the number of inches between the hem of a skirt and top of a knee" tends to "divert attention from substantive learning.

A school uniform is a uniform worn by students primarily for a school or otherwise educational institution.

They are common in primary and secondary schools in various countries. Although often used interchangeably, there is an important distinction between dress codes and school uniforms: according to scholars such as Nathan Joseph, clothing can only be considered a uniform when it "(a.

See e.g. Mary Julia Kuhn, Student Dress Codes in the Public Schools, 25 J. L. & Educ. 83, 97 () (explaining the story ofJake Rickets, a male student with numerous piercings and jewelry who, when told his attire was inappropriate, changed into a suit and met with.

Dress Code Change I would not like to have the new dress code change about if we should wear Uniforms to school. First of all if we do change the dress code and have to wear uniforms through K-8 grade would cost more money to buy the uniforms and get it in right sizes. The Article, “Clothing, dress codes & uniforms”, by David L. Hudson Jr. was featured in the K Public School Student Expression forum on Monday, April 1, The article explains how school officials have a responsibility to provide a safe, secure, and productive learning environment. The Debate Between School Dress Codes and Uniforms The debate over school uniforms and dress codes has been going on for years and is still widely debated and talked about in the education system. Each side of the argument has many supporters.

school district dress codes: Clothing and adornments; Tattoos; Piercings; Hair color Students will assume shared responsibility for collaborative work so students may present argument during debate.

K Public School Student Expression Overview | Freedom Forum Institute